The Legendary Dark Silkie Irish Whiskey Review: 'A Dangerous Temptress'

Sliabh Liag Distillers weaves a tale with The Legendary Silkie whiskeys, inspired by beings portrayed as alluring and irresistible. Several expressions have appeared over time, including the lightly peated The Legendary Dark Silkie. In this review, you’ll find out whether the whiskey is as legendary as the stories.

The Legendary Silkie range tells a story that resonates the world over. It’s rooted in creatures that surface throughout global folklore, sometimes under different names.

Names like silkie, undine, siren, ningyo, and yawkyawk all point to the same idea: a shape-shifting sea spirit, often female. At times she’s a captivating woman, sometimes a dangerous temptress luring men to their doom, and at others a mysterious figure forever yearning for the sea.

In the case of Sliabh Liag Distillers’ Irish whiskey, the story centers on a creature that changes from a seal into a beautiful woman, forever drawn back to her home: the Atlantic Ocean beyond Donegal’s cliffs.

The Dark Silkie takes the story in a slightly different direction. Think of it as chapter two, lifting the smoke a notch. The whiskey is a blend of double- and triple-distilled peated single malts. At its core it’s heavily peated at 55 Parts Per Million (PPM), which comes down to 22 PPM during distillation.

Where the Legendary Silkie Irish Whiskey is relatively tame on smoke, the Dark Silkie sets a more smoldering tone. You can already see it in the bottle presentation. The black label doesn’t just feature the mermaid that anchors the whiskey’s lore; it clearly calls out that this is an expression of “double-distilled and triple-distilled peated single malts.”

Opt for the gift tube and you’ll notice a familiar cue that hints at the peat: the mythical being emerging from a plume of smoke on the outer packaging. It’s a clever nod to the whisky’s character. But how smoky is it really?

In the glass, this gold-hued Irish whiskey looks pleasingly viscous. Even before you give it a swirl, fairly bold aromas rise up. The Silkie introduces itself as a mix of fruit with ashy tones and a warm, rubbery note.

After a moment to breathe, sweeter notes of overripe fruit appear—think green apple. You’ll also find fresh hints of mint leaf and spicier touches of black pepper. The ashy note continues to dominate, making this an easy recommendation for anyone who enjoys a whisper of smoke.

The first sip doesn’t immediately spring a surprise. There’s a peppery tingle at the back of the tongue and a creamy mouthfeel. As you linger, it’s as if the mysterious creature shifts shape.

Flavors of sweet fruit, malt, vanilla, and toffee glide in, balanced by a light tang. The whiskey bows out with a medium-length finish, letting a wisp of smoke have the final say.

Chapter two in a book of increasingly peated myths and legends—that’s perhaps the best way to describe Dark Silkie. The Legendary Silkie served as a gentle introduction to peat and smoke, and this Sliabh Liag Distillers expression simply turns the dial up. There’s more peat and more smoke, while a thread of sweetness still runs through it. This one clearly targets whiskey lovers who enjoy a touch more smoke and a firm tingle at the back of the palate.

+ Approachable and smooth, with a hint of peat

+ Drinks well neat and makes a solid base for a cocktail

- Benefits from a little time to breathe