Daftmill 2011 Summer Batch Release Whisky Review: 'Green APples and Crispy Fruits'

Some distilleries produce hundreds of thousands of liters of whisky a year, while others release only a handful of bottlings annually. Daftmill Distillery is one of the latter. This Lowlands producer looks ahead with a whisky that promises a bright, refreshing profile. The early bird catches the worm, but what about a golden-hued Lowlands whisky from a bourbon cask? Find out in this Daftmill 2011 Summer Batch Release Review.

Just above Pitlair in the Scottish Lowlands, whisky has been distilled since 2005. Brothers Francis and Ian Cuthbert converted part of their Daftmill farm into a distillery.

The Scottish water of life isn’t distilled year-round, nor in huge volumes, but in harmony with the rhythms of farm life. With most of the fieldwork falling in spring and autumn, summer and winter are partly reserved for whisky making. When producing the distillers’ beer, Daftmill ensures it runs from the mash tun as clean as possible. That clarity allows the grain’s character to shine once the whisky runs off the distillery’s two copper pot stills.

After distillation, the whisky is laid down in the warehouse, where the new make spirit can mature quietly until it’s time for a new release. Aside from a few single cask bottlings, Daftmill limits itself to a summer and a winter release. For the latter, this past winter saw a 2010 ex-bourbon cask used for maturing spirit. Now it’s time for the 2024 summer release. This year, the Cuthbert brothers have chosen a 12-year-old whisky drawn from various ex-bourbon casks.

The Daftmill 2011 Summer Release comes in the bottle the distillery always uses for its releases. At first glance, the label looks clean and tidy. No fuss, no frills,just straightforward information about the whisky on a white background. It’s a refreshing change from all the colorful artwork on a typical whisky shelf.

But don’t be fooled. It’s anything but a simple label. In fact, it’s a treasure trove of detail about the whisky in the bottle. Alongside the distillery name, ABV, and whisky designation, you’ll find the complete backstory of the spirit.

For the Summer Batch Release 2011, Daftmill selected casks that have been maturing since 2011. As always, the distillery states exactly how and when the spirit was made. In this case, Publican barley from field 43ac was used, harvested on 28 and 29 August 2009 (the same barley used for last year’s winter release).

It was then dried and ultimately malted in the summer of 2010, before being distilled into the spirit for this release. For maturation, Daftmill chose 27 first-fill bourbon barrels from Clermont Springs Distillery in Kentucky. It was bottled in 2023 at 46 percent alcohol by volume (ABV).

The Daftmill 2011 Summer Batch Release spent 12 years in first-fill ex-bourbon casks. You’d expect sweet and floral notes on the nose and that’s exactly what this limited whisky delivers, yet there’s a deeper layer that will intrigue seasoned whisky lovers. The distillation approach and the purity of the spirit at this whisky’s core leave ample room for discussion with every sip, and it all starts on the nose.

Your nostrils are first tickled by light, fresh notes of citrus, vanilla, and floral aromas. Then a layer emerges reminiscent of orchard fruits, ripe green apples and Spanish mandarins.

On the palate, this summery dram starts creamy and soft, though that sensation fades fairly quickly. It isn’t as sweet on the tongue as the nose suggests. Instead, it lands with a gentle tingle and shifts into notes of apple cider and other orchard fruit.

As the whisky dances in your mouth, flavors of ginger, a touch of salt, an underlying malty note, and light spices like nutmeg come through. The finish is medium in length, with each note bowing out in turn, leaving your mouth slightly dry. At the very end, Daftmill even hints at a dry white wine.

Summer can’t come soon enough. Daftmill Distillery has released a Lowlands single malt that underscores that feeling. It’s fresh, fruity, and floral without ever overplaying the summer vibe. Reading that it matured solely in ex-bourbon casks and was bottled at 46 percent, you might not expect this much depth from a farm-to-bottle whisky. It’s an approachable dram for newcomers, yet it also rewards settling in and pondering the whisky and the craft behind it.

+ Utterly enticing on the nose

+ Fresh and fruity without being overly “summery”

+ Accessible yet layered

- Not as sweet on the palate as the nose suggests